docs: add DBA grant script and Phase 1 VersionSet approval checklist

- scripts/dba/grant-migration-test-db-ownership.sql: for a DBA to run,
  fixes the kartsell_migration_test ownership regression blocking
  DbUpMigrationTests/DbUpRecoveryTests (12 tests) locally.
- docs/CURRENT/PHASE-1_APPROVAL_CHECKLIST.md +
  scripts/phase1/template-approve-versionset.sql: documents/templates the
  human maker-checker approval steps needed to freeze a VersionSet before
  Phase 1 shadow run can be re-queued. Does not perform any approval —
  every placeholder must be filled by a real, named maker and a different
  named checker. No automation should insert rows into dataset_manifest /
  model_version_registry / evidence_snapshot / release_evidence_bundle.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-08 12:39:18 +09:00
parent cedc8d79ee
commit 8c777df66b
3 changed files with 172 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,71 @@
# Phase 1 Shadow Run — VersionSet approval checklist
**Purpose:** `PHASE-1-SHADOW-RUN` (WBS tracker row, `docs/CURRENT/PHASE-1_SHADOW_RUN_STATUS_CORRECTION.md`)
is blocked because `evaluation.dataset_manifest`, `governance.model_version_registry`,
`signal_engine.evidence_snapshot`, and `governance.release_evidence_bundle` contain no
approved/frozen rows. Nothing can be RunId/JobId-enqueued until a human approves a VersionSet.
**This document is a checklist, not an approval.** It exists so the approval step is fast and
auditable once a real human decides to do it. It does not grant approval, and no automation in
this repository should insert rows into these tables on a schedule or "because the checklist
passed" — every `approved_by`/`checker_id` value below must be a real person who reviewed the
evidence, per CLAUDE.md's maker-checker principle and AGENTS.md's guardrail against fabricated
governance records.
## Why this can't be scripted away
Each table below enforces maker-checker at the database level (see the CHECK constraints in
`db/migrations/0016_continuous_model_operations.sql`, `0017_execution_assurance.sql`,
`0034_dataset_manifest_freeze_contract.sql`):
- `dataset_manifest`: `FROZEN` requires `approved_by`, `approved_at`, `frozen_at` all set, and the
table is append-only (trigger blocks UPDATE/DELETE — corrections are new rows).
- `model_version_registry`: `lifecycle_state = 'APPROVED'` requires `approved_by` + `approved_at`.
- `release_evidence_bundle`: `status IN ('APPROVED','REJECTED')` requires `checker_id IS NOT NULL`,
`checker_id <> maker_id` (the checker cannot be the maker), and `decided_at`.
There is no code path that satisfies these constraints without a named maker and a *different*
named checker actually deciding. That is intentional — do not add one.
## Checklist (walk in order)
1. **Dataset manifest exists and is content-addressed.**
- [ ] A `dataset_manifest` row exists for the target `scope_key` with `content_hash` computed
from the actual dataset (not a placeholder).
- [ ] `lineage_hash` traces back to real source ingestion (KRX/OpenDart/KIS via
`src/KArtSell.Modules.ModelOperations/Infrastructure/`), not synthetic/test data.
- [ ] A maker sets `status = 'PROPOSED'`.
- [ ] A **different** person (checker) reviews the dataset and, if acceptable, updates status to
`APPROVED` and later `FROZEN` (setting `approved_by`, `approved_at`, `frozen_at`).
2. **Model version registered.**
- [ ] `model_version_registry` row exists for the model/scope with `code_sha` matching the exact
commit that will run, `model_card_hash` matching a real ModelCard document.
- [ ] `lifecycle_state` progressed through `RESEARCH → CHALLENGER → SHADOW → CANDIDATE` with
real review at each step (not skipped).
- [ ] Checker sets `lifecycle_state = 'APPROVED'` with `approved_by`/`approved_at`.
3. **Evidence snapshot frozen.**
- [ ] `signal_engine.evidence_snapshot` row references the approved `dataset_id` and
`model_version` above, with `content_hash` computed from the actual frozen payload.
4. **Release evidence bundle.**
- [ ] `release_evidence_bundle` row aggregates build/test/migration/security/rollback artifact
hashes for the exact code that will run.
- [ ] Maker (`maker_id`) creates it in `DRAFT`/`REVIEW_REQUIRED`.
- [ ] A different checker (`checker_id <> maker_id`) reviews and sets `status = 'APPROVED'`,
`decided_at`.
5. **Only after all four are real and APPROVED/FROZEN:**
- [ ] Reconcile `shadow_run.check_status` constraint (already done — see
`db/migrations/0032_shadow_run_queued_status_contract.sql`, `AEG-X-004`).
- [ ] Call `POST /api/shadow-runs` referencing the approved VersionSet.
- [ ] Record the returned RunId/JobId in `docs/CURRENT/PHASE-1_SHADOW_RUN_STATUS_CORRECTION.md`
and update `WBS_PROGRESS_TRACKER.csv`'s `PHASE-1-SHADOW-RUN` row to `RUNNING` — only with that
real RunId/JobId cited as evidence.
## SQL template
`scripts/phase1/template-approve-versionset.sql` has the parameterized statements for steps 1-4,
with every value that must be a real human decision left as an explicit placeholder. It is a
template to hand-fill and run interactively (e.g. via `psql`), not a script to execute as-is.
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
-- DEBT: AEG-X-004 regression (2026-08-07) — see docs/CURRENT/CATALOGS/WBS_PROGRESS_TRACKER.csv row AEG-X-004
-- and CURRENT_ROADMAP.md "알려진 문서 정합성 문제" #2.
--
-- Symptom: 12 DbUpMigrationTests (Migration0008/0009/0010/0032) fail locally with
-- Postgres 42501 "must be owner of database kartsell_migration_test" — the `kartsell`
-- DB user can no longer DROP+CREATE that database, which the fresh/upgrade/re-run
-- rehearsal requires.
--
-- Run this as a Postgres superuser (or the role that currently owns kartsell_migration_test)
-- against the target server, NOT as the `kartsell` application user (it cannot grant itself
-- ownership of a database it does not already own).
--
-- Usage:
-- psql -h <host> -p 5432 -U <superuser> -d postgres -f scripts/dba/grant-migration-test-db-ownership.sql
ALTER DATABASE kartsell_migration_test OWNER TO kartsell;
-- If the database does not exist yet on this server, create it first, then re-run the ALTER
-- above (CREATE DATABASE already makes the creating role the owner, so the ALTER becomes a
-- no-op in that case):
-- CREATE DATABASE kartsell_migration_test OWNER kartsell;
-- Verify:
-- SELECT datname, pg_catalog.pg_get_userbyid(datdba) AS owner
-- FROM pg_database WHERE datname = 'kartsell_migration_test';
-- Expected: owner = kartsell
-- After this grant, re-run the isolated rehearsal to confirm:
-- dotnet test --filter "FullyQualifiedName~DbUpMigrationTests" -c Release
-- dotnet test --filter "FullyQualifiedName~DbUpRecoveryTests" -c Release
@@ -0,0 +1,71 @@
-- Phase 1 Shadow Run — VersionSet approval TEMPLATE.
-- See docs/CURRENT/PHASE-1_APPROVAL_CHECKLIST.md before touching this file.
--
-- THIS IS NOT A SCRIPT TO RUN AS-IS. Every :placeholder below must be filled in by a real
-- person who actually reviewed the referenced evidence. Do not fill these in programmatically,
-- from a template default, or because "the checklist items are all checked" — the checker must
-- be a different person from the maker, and both must be named humans who can be held
-- accountable for the decision. Running this file IS the approval action.
--
-- Usage: fill in every :placeholder, remove this comment block, then run interactively:
-- psql "$KARTSELL_POSTGRES" -f scripts/phase1/template-approve-versionset.sql
-- Do not run non-interactively / in CI / from a job.
begin;
-- 1) Dataset manifest: propose, then (as a DIFFERENT session/person) approve + freeze.
insert into evaluation.dataset_manifest
(dataset_id, scope_key, content_hash, source_catalog_version, lineage_hash, status, frozen_at)
values
(:'dataset_id', :'scope_key', :'content_hash', :'source_catalog_version', :'lineage_hash',
'PROPOSED', now());
-- -- Run as a SEPARATE step by the checker, after real review, not in the same transaction:
-- update evaluation.dataset_manifest
-- set status = 'APPROVED', approved_by = :'checker_name', approved_at = now()
-- where dataset_id = :'dataset_id';
-- -- table is append-only after that point; freezing requires a new row, not an UPDATE to FROZEN
-- -- (see db/migrations/0034_dataset_manifest_freeze_contract.sql trigger) — insert a follow-up
-- -- row with status = 'FROZEN' and the same content_hash lineage instead.
-- 2) Model version registry.
insert into governance.model_version_registry
(model_version, scope_key, config_version, code_sha, contract_version, lifecycle_state,
effective_at, model_card_hash)
values
(:'model_version', :'scope_key', :'config_version', :'code_sha', :'contract_version',
'CANDIDATE', now(), :'model_card_hash');
-- -- Checker step, separately, after real review:
-- update governance.model_version_registry
-- set lifecycle_state = 'APPROVED', approved_by = :'checker_name', approved_at = now()
-- where model_version = :'model_version' and scope_key = :'scope_key' and effective_at = :'effective_at';
-- 3) Evidence snapshot (references the approved dataset + model version above).
insert into signal_engine.evidence_snapshot
(evidence_id, as_of, published_at_cutoff, dataset_id, data_hash, model_version,
config_version, payload, content_hash)
values
(:'evidence_id', now(), :'published_at_cutoff', :'dataset_id', :'data_hash',
:'model_version', :'config_version', :'payload_json'::jsonb, :'content_hash');
-- 4) Release evidence bundle — maker creates, a DIFFERENT checker approves.
insert into governance.release_evidence_bundle
(bundle_id, release_version, source_manifest_hash, build_artifact_hash, test_artifact_hash,
migration_artifact_hash, security_artifact_hash, rollback_artifact_hash, decision_log_hash,
status, maker_id, created_at, content_hash)
values
(gen_random_uuid(), :'release_version', :'source_manifest_hash', :'build_artifact_hash',
:'test_artifact_hash', :'migration_artifact_hash', :'security_artifact_hash',
:'rollback_artifact_hash', :'decision_log_hash', 'REVIEW_REQUIRED', :'maker_name', now(),
:'bundle_content_hash');
-- -- Checker step, separately, after real review (checker_id must differ from maker_id — enforced
-- -- by CHECK constraint):
-- update governance.release_evidence_bundle
-- set status = 'APPROVED', checker_id = :'checker_name', decided_at = now()
-- where bundle_id = :'bundle_id';
-- Do not COMMIT this transaction until you are the maker completing steps above as one unit.
-- The checker updates are separate transactions run later by a different person.
commit;