# K-ArtSell Aegis AI Coding Constitution v16.0

## 🔒 GOVERNANCE LOCK

**AGENTS.md IS THE ONLY AUTHORITATIVE SOURCE FOR ENGINEERING GUIDELINES.**

**Rules (Non-negotiable):**
1. **All engineering procedures, harnesses, and decision frameworks go in AGENTS.md only.**
2. **CLAUDE.md, GEMINI.md, and all other .md files follow AGENTS.md. They do NOT define rules.**
3. **If any document conflicts with AGENTS.md, AGENTS.md wins. Other text is void.**
4. **Never add guidelines to CLAUDE.md, GEMINI.md, or side documents.**
5. **Supplementary files reference AGENTS.md with explicit links only.**

**Scope:**
- **AGENTS.md owns:** Coding rules, development setup, procedures, harnesses, decision frameworks, anti-patterns, workflows
- **Other files provide:** Project status, architecture context, navigation, references (links to AGENTS.md)

**Enforcement:**
- Claude Code will not accept conflicting guidance from multiple sources
- When in doubt, check AGENTS.md section headers
- If you see conflicting guidance elsewhere, update that document to reference AGENTS.md instead

## Default execution procedure

All work in this repository MUST follow `docs/CURRENT/WBS_EXECUTION_PROCEDURES.md` as the default operating procedure, together with this constitution. Before editing, select exactly one WBS item from `docs/CURRENT/CATALOGS/WBS_MASTER.csv`, verify dependencies, Gate, Requirement/API/DB/Job/UI/Test IDs, Acceptance_Evidence, and Artifact. Record Source / Assumption / Unknown / Decision Required, then execute, collect actual evidence, update `WBS_PROGRESS_TRACKER.csv`, and commit with the WBS_ID. Do not mark a WBS item COMPLETED or claim a test/build/migration result without preserved execution evidence.

1. 자동주문과 KIS 제출 Capability는 OFF다. 별도 승인 Release 전 구현·활성화·우회하지 않는다.
2. 채팅과 생성 코드는 Source of Truth가 아니다. 모든 변경은 Source / Assumption / Unknown / Decision Required를 표시한다.
3. 한 PR은 한 Vertical Slice 또는 한 동작보존 리팩터링 목적만 가진다.
4. Endpoint→Application→Pure Policy→Dapper SQL→Outbox→Tests 경계를 지킨다.
5. Domain Policy는 시간·랜덤·네트워크·DB·DI Container를 직접 읽지 않는다.
6. Generic Repository, God Service, Service Locator, Job 내 비즈니스 정책, 조기 Microservice 분리를 금지한다.
7. 모듈은 다른 모듈 Source Table을 직접 조회하지 않는다. 승인된 Contract/Read Model만 사용한다.
8. `DateTime.Now/UtcNow`를 직접 사용하지 않고 IClock과 MarketCalendar를 사용한다.
9. 금융값은 decimal, 명시적 rounding, 단위 계약을 사용한다. 모델 내부 double은 경계에서 변환한다.
10. `SellRatioOfLot`, `SellQuantity`, `TargetPortfolioWeightAfter`, `StrategicCoreFloorWeight`를 혼용하지 않는다.
11. EvidenceSnapshot·DatasetId·Model/Config/Code SHA 없이 Decision/Recommendation을 저장하지 않는다.
12. Command/Job는 IdempotencyKey/JobRunId/Watermark를 갖고 replay를 견딘다.
13. Evidence/Decision/Audit는 update/delete하지 않고 append/correction event로 보존한다.
14. Write Model은 정규화·append·revision, 화면은 version/watermark/rebuild가 있는 Read Model이다.
15. 서버 상태는 TanStack Query가 소유한다. Pinia에 API 응답을 복제하지 않는다.
16. FE request/response는 Zod로 runtime validation하고 같은 retry에 같은 Idempotency-Key를 재사용한다.
17. `/internal/*` Endpoint는 Roles 또는 Policies를 선언하며 익명 접근을 허용하지 않는다.
18. 알고리즘 변경은 Policy ID, Golden, Frozen OOS, cost×2, false-exit/reentry/ES, ModelCard를 동반한다.
19. 새 library/pattern/table/threshold는 ADR/Issue 승인 없이 도입하지 않는다.
20. 실행하지 못한 build/test/migration을 통과했다고 기록하지 않는다.
21. AI 생성 Migration은 fresh/upgrade/re-run/failure rehearsal 및 DBA 승인 없이는 병합하지 않는다.
22. 실고객 데이터·실계좌·실주문 키·secret를 prompt/fixture/log/trace에 넣지 않는다.
23. Metric·Alert·Runbook·Rollback·Owner/Secondary가 없으면 Done이 아니다.


## v12.1 execution-readiness delta

- Every change must cite Requirement/Slice/Policy/Data/API/DB/Job/UI/Test IDs.
- Production commands load Evidence/Model/Config from approved server-side PIT context; never trust client-supplied evidence.
- Write models are normalized and append/correction based. Denormalization is allowed only in versioned, rebuildable read models.
- Outbox/Inbox/JobRun/Projection operations require scope, idempotency, watermark, hashes, and replay evidence.
- No generic repository, God service, reflection plugin framework, premature microservice, or unapproved threshold.
- Refactoring and policy changes must be separate PRs with characterization or Golden tests first.
- Never claim a build, migration, test, Shadow period, PBO, or DSR result that was not executed and preserved as evidence.

## v12.2 strategic data-semantics delta

- `CurrentSecurityPortfolioWeight`, `CurrentLotPortfolioWeight`, `SellRatioOfLot`, and `StrategicCoreFloorWeight` are distinct units. Never reintroduce the ambiguous `CurrentPortfolioWeight` into active decision code.
- A lot-relative sell changes security weight by `CurrentLotPortfolioWeight * SellRatioOfLot`.
- Persist the ordered policy trace with Applied/Blocked/NotApplicable dispositions; do not expose raw internal scores directly to customers.
- Prior migrations are immutable. v12.2 changes belong in migration `0014` or later.
- The six current-session attachments and their SHA-256 values are part of the release evidence.
- Use the reviewed templates under `templates/`; do not bulk-generate unapproved modules or placeholder implementations.

## v12.3 execution and semantic-version delta

- `weight_semantics_version=1` contexts are legacy ambiguous data and must never enter active decisions; rebuild them as version 2 from explicit security and lot weights.
- A positive opportunity edge with a zero or missing requested sell ratio is BLOCKED. Never clamp missing intent to a minimum sell.
- Policy IDs, priorities and thresholds must match `contracts/policies/sell-policy-contract.v1.json`; drift blocks G2.
- Decision/API/Event/DB evidence must preserve `decision_contract_version` and `policy_trace_schema_version`.
- Outcome metrics must name a definition version, population, numerator, denominator, window and aggregation. Do not equate 63-session research output with an annual target without approval.
- `scripts/scaffold_slice.py` is dry-run by default, refuses overwrite and produces SCAFFOLD_ONLY code. Generated files are not approved implementation.
- The seven cumulative attachments and their SHA-256 values are part of v12.3 release evidence.

## v12.4 Model Operations Constitution

- Scheduler automation is limited to EVALUATION_ONLY, PROPOSAL_ONLY and DRILL_ONLY.
- Never generate or merge automatic model promotion, rollback, threshold mutation, code change, automatic order or KIS submission paths.
- Every evaluation request freezes Dataset/Model/Config/Code/Contract VersionSet from an approved server-side context.
- Metric changes require a versioned numerator, denominator, window, aggregation, PIT/revision rule and Golden/OOS impact.
- Improvement proposals are documents and records only; they do not edit model, policy, configuration or source files.
- Drift thresholds, false-exit definition and retention policy are DECISION_REQUIRED until approved.

## v14.0 UI / Model Feedback non-negotiables
- Feature code MUST NOT import PrimeVue or AG Grid directly. Use shared UI ports and screen types.
- UI provider changes require contract, accessibility, visual, state-matrix and performance evidence.
- Model operation automation stops at evaluation/proposal. Model activation is human change approval only.
- J39 and every new schedule remain disabled until their source, calendar, ownership and alert contracts are approved.
- Never claim .NET, pnpm, PostgreSQL, Playwright or Shadow evidence passed unless the actual artifact is attached.
- **[CRITICAL IRON RULE] Viewport-Fit Zero-Scroll Layout**: Except for analytical dashboards, ALL workstation screens MUST fit 100% within the initial viewport upon loading WITHOUT page-level window scrolling. All primary grids, forms, and control panels must automatically calculate `height: calc(100vh - header/tabs)` and handle internal scrolling inside containers.
- **[CRITICAL IRON RULE] Standardized Button Layout Strategy**:
  1. **Page Action Toolbar (Top-Right `.ks-page__actions`)**: Dedicated exclusively to **Primary Processing Actions** (e.g., `▶ 배치 실행`, `⚡ 리밸런싱 실행`, `📤 데이터 수집`) and **Global Page Operations** (e.g., `➕ 신규 등록`). Secondary actions are styled as outline/ghost.
  2. **Grid Row & Item Context Actions (Table Row Actions)**: Dedicated to **Single-Row CRUD & Processing** (e.g., `✏️ 수정`, `🗑️ 삭제`, `🔍 상세보기`, `▶ 재처리`). Placed in a pinned right column or explicit context menu; never placed in page top toolbar.
  3. **Multi-Selection Batch Toolbar (Grid Top/Bottom Selection Bar)**: Activated conditionally upon multi-row selection for **Bulk Actions** (e.g., `선택 일괄 승인(3)`, `선택 일괄 삭제`).
- **[CRITICAL IRON RULE] Standardized Loading Skeleton Rule**: ALL screen-level and section-level data loading MUST render animated `SkeletonLoader` (shimmer mode) matching the expected layout (e.g. `skeletonType="table"` for grids, `skeletonType="card"` for forms/summaries) through `QueryStateBoundary`/`StandardScreenBoundary`. Static text ("불러오는 중...") or empty screen placeholders during loading states are STRICTLY PROHIBITED.
- **[CRITICAL IRON RULE] Standardized Empty Data State Rule**: When zero records or empty dataset states occur, ALL grids, lists, and summary cards MUST render standard `EmptyStatePlaceholder` component (`📭` icon, clear title, descriptive helper text, and optional recovery action button). Blank white spaces or plain `<p>데이터가 없습니다</p>` text tags are STRICTLY PROHIBITED.
- **[CRITICAL IRON RULE] Standardized Form & Filter Control Width Rule**: ALL form & filter controls MUST adhere to central default width tokens (`tokens.css` / `base.css`). Controls MUST NOT stretch to 100% full width inside filter bars unless explicitly grouped in full-width grid layouts:
  1. **Select / Dropdown (`select`, `.p-select`, `.ks-select`)**: Default width `--ks-control-width-select` (`160px`).
  2. **Search Input (`.search-input`)**: Default width `--ks-control-width-search` (`220px`).
  3. **Date Picker (`input[type="date"]`)**: Default width `--ks-control-width-date` (`140px`).
- **[CRITICAL IRON RULE] Standardized Grid Row Numbering Rule**: Unless explicitly disabled (`showRowNumber: false`), ALL data grids MUST automatically prepend a pinned left `No.` column rendering 1-indexed sequential row numbers (`node.rowIndex + 1`) centered with `54px` fixed width.
- **[CRITICAL IRON RULE] Standardized Grid Theme, Zebra Stripes & Color Palette Rule**: ALL data grids MUST inherit central Theme Color Tokens (`tokens.css`) without ad-hoc inline overrides. Grids MUST enforce:
  1. **Header Background**: Premium Header Gray `#f1f5f9` (Dark Mode: `#1e293b`), font-weight: `700`.
  2. **Zebra Stripes (Odd Rows)**: Even rows `#ffffff`, Odd rows (`.ag-row-odd`) `#f8fafc` (Dark Mode: `#0f172a`).
  3. **Hover Color**: Sky Light Blue `#e0f2fe` (Dark Mode: `#334155`).
  4. **Active Selection Color**: Active Selected Row Sky Blue `#dbeafe` with bold text `#1e3a8a` (Dark Mode: `#1e3a8a`).

## v16.0 Gitea API & CI/CD Automation

### Environment Setup

**Gitea API Token:**
```bash
# Set GITEA_TOKEN_TAXBAIK environment variable
# This token enables:
# - Pull request automation (labels, milestones, comments)
# - Issue management (create, update, close)
# - Release management (tags, release notes)
# - CI/CD pipeline integration

# On Windows (PowerShell):
$env:GITEA_TOKEN_TAXBAIK = "your-token-here"

# On macOS/Linux (bash):
export GITEA_TOKEN_TAXBAIK="your-token-here"

# Verify:
echo $GITEA_TOKEN_TAXBAIK
```

### Gitea API Patterns

**Common endpoints (https://gitea.taxbaik.com/api/v1):**

```bash
# Create a PR comment
curl -X POST \
  -H "Authorization: token $GITEA_TOKEN_TAXBAIK" \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  -d '{"body":"Verification complete: 41/41 tests passed"}' \
  https://gitea.taxbaik.com/api/v1/repos/kjh2064/KArtSell.Aegis/issues/{issue_id}/comments

# Add labels to PR
curl -X POST \
  -H "Authorization: token $GITEA_TOKEN_TAXBAIK" \
  -d '["architecture","verified"]' \
  https://gitea.taxbaik.com/api/v1/repos/kjh2064/KArtSell.Aegis/issues/{pr_number}/labels

# Create release with notes
curl -X POST \
  -H "Authorization: token $GITEA_TOKEN_TAXBAIK" \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  -d '{"tag_name":"v16.0.1","body":"Release notes..."}' \
  https://gitea.taxbaik.com/api/v1/repos/kjh2064/KArtSell.Aegis/releases

# Query PR/Issue
curl -H "Authorization: token $GITEA_TOKEN_TAXBAIK" \
  https://gitea.taxbaik.com/api/v1/repos/kjh2064/KArtSell.Aegis/pulls?state=open
```

### CI/CD Integration (Gitea Actions)

**Leverage in `.gitea/workflows/ci.yml`:**

```yaml
- name: Comment on PR with test results
  if: github.event_name == 'pull_request'
  run: |
    curl -X POST \
      -H "Authorization: token ${{ secrets.GITEA_TOKEN }}" \
      -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
      -d "{\"body\":\"Build: ✅ Tests: 41/41 PASS\"}" \
      https://gitea.taxbaik.com/api/v1/repos/kjh2064/KArtSell.Aegis/issues/${{ github.event.pull_request.number }}/comments
```

### Automation Best Practices (from v16.0)

- **PR Labels:** Auto-label based on affected module (e.g., `ModelOperations`, `SignalEngine`)
- **Milestones:** Link PRs to quarterly sprints for burndown tracking
- **Comments:** Post verification results (build, test, security scan) directly on PR

## v16.0 Development Environment Configuration

### Database & Backend Setup

**DO NOT make up or ask for database credentials.**

Read `src/KArtSell.Host/appsettings.Development.json` directly. Current values:
```json
{
  "ConnectionStrings": {
    "Postgres": "Host=127.0.0.1;Port=5432;Database=kartselldb;Username=kartsell;Password=kartsell4321@!"
  },
  "Authentication": {
    "Mode": "DevelopmentHeader"
  }
}
```

**Connection Parameters:**
- Host: `127.0.0.1` (localhost)
- Port: `5432`
- Database: `kartselldb` (NOT `kartsell`)
- Username: `kartsell`
- Password: `kartsell4321@!`

**SSH Tunnel (Required before starting backend):**
```powershell
ssh -L 5432:127.0.0.1:5432 kjh2064@178.104.200.7
```

**Start Backend (use config file, no env var injection):**
```powershell
cd D:\JobRoomz\KArtSell.Aegis
dotnet run --project src/KArtSell.Host --configuration Debug --no-build
```

### Frontend Development Server

**Port:** 5174 (fallback: 5173 if available)

**Start Frontend (from project root):**
```bash
cd frontend
pnpm install --frozen-lockfile
pnpm dev
```

**URL:** http://localhost:5174

### Frontend Layout & Responsive Design Standards (v16.0)

**CRITICAL:** Responsive web design is MANDATORY for all layouts, not optional.

#### CSS Variable Standards (base.css)
```css
:root {
  --ks-sidebar-width: 16rem;       /* Navigation sidebars */
  --ks-aside-width: 22rem;         /* Side panels */
  --ks-preview-width: 24rem;       /* Preview/summary panels */
  --ks-detail-width: 28rem;        /* Detail panels */
  --ks-content-max: 1400px;        /* Max content width (prevent excessive expansion) */
}
```

#### Layout Rules (Non-Negotiable)
1. **NO hardcoded pixel/rem widths in minmax.** Always use CSS variables: `minmax(0, 1fr) var(--ks-aside-width)` ✅, NOT `minmax(18rem, 26rem)` ❌
2. **Unified breakpoints (all layouts must use same):**
   - **Desktop:** Default (no constraint)
   - **Tablet:** `@media (max-width: 1100px) { grid-template-columns: 1fr; }` (2-col → 1-col)
   - **Mobile:** `@media (max-width: 768px) { /* adjust padding, font sizes */ }`
3. **All flex children:** `flex: 1; min-height: 0;` required (prevents overflow squashing)
4. **Scrollable containers:** `overflow-y: auto; min-height: 0;` (enables internal scroll without page scroll)
5. **Grid layouts:** `align-items: start;` (NOT center/stretch) to prevent column stretching at different heights
6. **Max-width constraint:** Wrap pages in `.page-wrapper { max-width: var(--ks-content-max); margin: 0 auto; }` to prevent 2560px+ distortion
7. **PageLayout must use CSS Grid (NOT flexbox).** Flex + gap breaks `flex: 1` height propagation in children:
   - ❌ **DON'T:** `display: flex; flex-direction: column; gap: var(--ks-space-2);` (gap is not counted in flex: 1 calculations)
   - ✅ **DO:** `display: grid; grid-template-rows: auto auto auto auto 1fr auto auto; gap: var(--ks-space-2);` (gap auto-calculated)
   - **Reason:** Grid gap is accounted for in row sizing; flex gap is invisible to flex: 1 child height calculations, causing overflow → unwanted scroll
   - **Template rows:** header (auto) | subtitle (auto) | commandBar (auto) | summary (auto) | filters (auto) | workspace (1fr) | footer (auto)

#### Page Structure Rule: NO Footers (Global or Page-Level)
**CRITICAL:** Footers are EXCLUDED at all levels:
1. **Page-level footers** (PageLayout #footer slot) — ❌ FORBIDDEN
2. **Global footers** (AppShellLayout footer) — ❌ REMOVED
3. **All footer functionality** must be relocated to:
   - **Primary actions:** `<template #actions>` (header right side) — e.g., Help, AI Suggest
   - **Command bar:** `<template #commandBar>` — e.g., Save, Reset, Approve buttons
   - **Status info:** `<template #summary>` — e.g., Watermark, Owner, System status

**Design Principle: Maximize Screen Real Estate**
- Footers waste ~48-64px of viewport height (non-recoverable on mobile)
- Single-screen principle: ALL controls must be visible without scrolling
- Mobile UX: bottom footer is hardest to reach (thumb-friendly zone = top 60%, sides)
- Information density: header/command-bar/summary can convey all necessary context
- Content-first: Every pixel should serve user goal, not chrome

**Example Migration:**
```vue
<!-- ❌ DON'T: Use footer -->
<PageLayout title="Market Data Import">
  <template #footer>
    <button @click="reset">초기화</button>
    <button @click="schedule">수집 예약</button>
  </template>
</PageLayout>

<!-- ✅ DO: Move to command bar -->
<PageLayout title="Market Data Import">
  <template #commandBar>
    <button @click="reset">초기화</button>
    <button @click="schedule">수집 예약</button>
  </template>
</PageLayout>
```

**Implementation:**
- PageLayout: `<template #footer>` must be removed (do not use)
- AppShellLayout: Global footer completely removed
- All pages: Design with content ending at viewport edge (no footer gap)

#### Height Propagation Chain (Single-Screen Principle)
```
PageLayout (.ks-page__content)
  ├─ height: 100%; min-height: 0; display: flex;
  ↓
QueryStateBoundary (.ks-query-boundary)
  ├─ flex: 1; height: 100%; min-height: 0; display: flex;
  ↓
Content Container (KsSplitter, .ks-stack, FormPageLayout)
  ├─ flex: 1; min-height: 0; height: 100%;
  ├─ display: flex/grid;
  ↓
Internal Panes (.request-list, .detail-panel, .items)
  ├─ flex: 1; min-height: 0; overflow-y: auto;
```

#### Banned Patterns
- ❌ `grid-template-columns: minmax(18rem, 26rem)` (hardcoded min/max)
- ❌ `calc(100vh - Xpx)` (brittle, changes with header size)
- ❌ `max-width: 600px` on full-page containers (prevents responsiveness)
- ❌ `align-items: center` in grid layouts (prevents height-based alignment)
- ❌ `position: fixed` sidebars without mobile fallback
- ❌ Multiple different breakpoints across layouts (950px, 900px, 1000px, 1200px all mixed)

#### Verification Checklist
For every layout change:
- [ ] Uses CSS variables, not hardcoded rem/px
- [ ] Breakpoints are 1100px (tablet) and 768px (mobile)
- [ ] All flex children have `flex: 1; min-height: 0`
- [ ] All scrollable panes have `overflow-y: auto; min-height: 0`
- [ ] Tested at 768px (mobile), 1100px (tablet breakpoint), 1512px (current test), 1920px (fullHD), 2560px (4K)
- [ ] No page-level scroll on first load (only internal pane scroll if needed)
- [ ] Content max-width prevents distortion on ultra-wide (>1400px)

#### Affected Layouts (Status)
| Layout | Issue | Status | Reason |
|--------|-------|--------|--------|
| PageLayout | None | ✅ COMPLIANT | Uses CSS variables |
| CrudWorkspaceLayout | None | ✅ COMPLIANT | Uses CSS variables |
| FormPageLayout | Hardcoded `minmax(18rem, 26rem)` | 🔴 FIX REQUIRED | Session 2026-08-16 |
| ReviewWorkbenchLayout | Mixed hardcoded widths | 🔴 FIX REQUIRED | Session 2026-08-16 |
| OperationsConsoleLayout | Hardcoded `minmax(18rem, 28rem)` | 🔴 FIX REQUIRED | Session 2026-08-16 |

### Authentication for Testing

Development mode uses `DevelopmentHeaderAuthenticationHandler`. Test requests with:
```powershell
$headers = @{
    "X-KArtSell-User" = "kjh2064"
    "X-KArtSell-Role" = "Admin"
    "Content-Type" = "application/json"
}

Invoke-WebRequest -Uri "http://127.0.0.1:5002/api/shadow-runs" `
    -Method POST `
    -Headers $headers `
    -Body $body
```

### Rules for Development Configuration

1. **Never invent credentials.** Read config files first.
2. **Never ask the user for settings.** Read `appsettings.Development.json` directly.
3. **Database name is `kartselldb`.** Not `kartsell`.
4. **SSH tunnel is mandatory.** PostgreSQL is not accessible without it.
5. **Authentication mode is `DevelopmentHeader`.** Use headers, not OIDC tokens.
- **Releases:** Tag with semver + architecture contract version (e.g., `v16.0.1-contract-v3.0`)
- **Issue Linking:** Reference debt IDs, ADRs, decision logs in commits (e.g., `TECH-001: Fix CA1822`)

---

## v16.0 Strategic Architecture & Engineering Excellence

### Decision Criteria for All Work

Every task — code change, refactor, new feature, tooling, infrastructure — must be evaluated against these dimensions before implementation:

#### 1. SOLID 원칙
- **S**ingle Responsibility: One class, one reason to change. Vertical Slice boundaries are trust boundaries.
- **O**pen/Closed: Open for extension (new Policies, new decision gates); closed for modification (immutable Evidence, append-only migrations).
- **L**iskov Substitution: Handlers, Policies, Adapters are swappable; never break contract.
- **I**nterface Segregation: IClock ≠ IDateTime; IOutboxWriter ≠ IEventBus. Ports are narrow.
- **D**ependency Inversion: Depend on abstractions (IClock, ILogger, IOutboxWriter); inject concretions at composition root only.
- **적용:** 모듈 경계 설계, 인터페이스 분리, 스태틱 메서드 vs 인스턴스 메서드 판단.

#### 2. 코드 리팩토링 (Code Mass & Complexity)
- Cyclomatic Complexity ≤ 10 per method (Policy는 예외: decision trees는 복잡해질 수 있음).
- Characterize → Isolate → Transform → Verify → Simplify → Observe → Close Debt (정공법).
- Dead code, unused flags, unreachable branches는 즉시 삭제. "혹시 필요할까봐"는 금지.
- Performance refactor와 기능 변경은 분리된 PR. 동시 변경은 회귀 탐지 불가.

#### 3. 데이터 정합성 (Data Integrity & Audit)
- **PIT (Point-in-Time):** `WHERE published_at <= cutoff AND revision = latest` 필수. 시간 여행 쿼리는 audit 목적만.
- **Revision Tracking:** update/delete 금지. 새 버전을 append로 저장. 수정은 correction event로 보존.
- **Audit Trail:** EvidenceSnapshot, DatasetId, Model/Config/Code SHA는 Decision과 함께 저장. Trace 불가능하면 미완성.
- **적용:** 모든 쓰기는 append/correction 패턴. 읽기는 PIT 조건. 마이그레이션은 회원가입 없음.

#### 4. 과유불급 (Necessity-Driven, No Gold-Plating)
- "혹시 나중에 필요하면"으로 코드를 추가하지 않는다. 근거 없는 추상화 금지.
- 한 곳에서만 쓰면 분리하지 않는다. 세 곳에서 반복되면 그때 abstract.
- Feature flag, backward-compat shim, deprecation layer는 근거 있을 때만. 사용하지 않는 코드는 삭제.
- **적용:** 새 service/interface/config 도입 전에 "이것이 정말 필요한가?" 자문.

#### 5. 정규화 & 역정규화 (Normalization Strategy)
- **Write Models:** 3NF + append + revision. 중복 없음, 관계 명확, 이상 불가.
- **Read Models:** Denormalized projections. 1NF 위반 허용 (성능, 접근성). 모든 Read는 versioned, rebuildable.
- **경계:** Write는 Dapper로 스키마-규정. Read는 쿼리 최적화. 양쪽 스키마 감시.
- **적용:** 새 column 추가 전에 "이것은 3NF 위반인가? 그렇다면 projection으로."

#### 6. 프로세스 단순화 (Simplicity & Clarity)
- 한 번에 한 가지만 한다. 다중 책임 = 다중 이해 실패 = 버그.
- "왜 이 순서인가?" 묻지 않아도 명확한 코드. 숨겨진 전제 금지.
- Circular dependency, magic numbers, implicit state 제거.
- **적용:** 코드 흐름이 위→아래로 읽혀야 함. 뒤로 돌아가며 읽어야 하면 리팩터.

#### 7. 패턴화, 표준화, 구조화 (Patterns & Standards)
- Vertical Slice는 단일 패턴. Endpoint → Handler → Policy → Dapper → Outbox.
- Job은 단일 책임. 비즈니스 정책은 들어가지 않음. 승인된 Command만 실행.
- Event schema는 contract-first. 구독자가 없으면 이벤트도 없음.
- **표준 컴포넌트:** QueryStateBoundary, CrudForm, PermissionGuard 등은 모든 화면에서 재사용. 직접 import 금지.
- **적용:** 새 pattern/component 도입 전 팀 검토. 코드 사본 3개 = abstract 신호.

#### 8. 바이브코딩 & 홀루시네이션 통제 (AI Guardrails)
- AI 생성 코드는 근거 없음. Source/Assumption/Decision 반드시 기록.
- **금지:** 근거 없는 Policy ID, threshold, DB column, API endpoint.
- SQL은 schema owner, PIT 조건, index, execution plan 검토 필수.
- 알고리즘 변경은 Golden/Frozen OOS diff 없이 병합 금지.
- **적용:** "이 값은 어디서 나왔나?" 묻는 습관. 답 없으면 DECISION_REQUIRED 표시.

#### 9. 현장감, 재현성, 이력성 (Traceability & Reproducibility)
- **현장감:** Build/test/migration artifact는 보존. "통과했다고 주장"하되 증거 없으면 거짓.
- **재현성:** 동일 input → 동일 output. Random, network, system time 의존은 격리. Mock 금지, integration test로.
- **이력성:** Commit message는 "왜"를 기록. "버그 수정"은 불충분. "X 기능에서 Y 조건에서 Z 버그 → 원인: 로직 오류" 기록.
- **적용:** CI/CD 결과물 저장, 회귀 테스트 잠금, ADR에 의사결정 기록.

#### 10. 안정성 (Reliability & Safety)
- Idempotency: 같은 요청 → 같은 결과. 두 번 실행해도 안전.
- Rollback 불가능한 변경 금지. Migration도 down script 필수.
- Failure mode: 각 Job/Endpoint은 실패했을 때 상태를 명확히. "실패했는데 부분 성공?" 금지.
- **적용:** Command/Job는 IdempotencyKey, Watermark 필수. DB constraint, NOT NULL 검증.

#### 11. 고도화 & 컴포넌트화 (Componentization & Maturity)
- 한 번 제대로. 임시방편 금지. 기술부채는 Debt register에 기록.
- 구현 전 contract/schema/test 먼저. "하면서 배운다"는 설계 부실의 신호.
- 버전 관리: 기능이 아닌 contract 버전. API/Event/DB schema 버전 분리.
- **적용:** Release note에는 contract version, breaking change, migration step 명시.

#### 12. 정공법 (Right Way, Not Shortcuts)
- 안 되는 길에 시간 낭비하지 말되, 편한 길도 피한다 (--no-verify, force push).
- 문제 근본 해결. Symptom 치료는 debt 증가.
- 리뷰어가 "이게 최선인가?" 묻는 코드는 재작성. "충분히 좋다" ≠ "최선".
- **적용:** Build 실패 → --no-verify X, 원인 파악. Merge conflict → cherry-pick X, rebase 제대로.

#### 13. 기술부채 관리 (Tech Debt Registry)
- 부채는 기록하는 순간부터 이자 발생. 미루지 말 것.
- **Debt ID:** TECH-001 등으로 추적. PR/commit에서 참조.
- **우선순위:** Impact (얼마나 큰가) × Effort (고치는 데 드는 비용). 고영향 저비용 우선.
- **Paydown:** 분기마다 debt 20% 감축 목표. 신규 debt > paydown이면 질식.
- **적용:** README.md의 TECH_DEBT_REGISTER 매월 검토. 3개월 미해결 = 리팩터 스프린트 필요.

### Work Decision Checklist

모든 task에 대해 다음을 자문:

- [ ] **SOLID:** 이 변경이 단일 책임인가? Dependency inversion을 지킬 것인가?
- [ ] **Complexity:** 함수/메서드 복잡도는 10 이하인가? (Policy 예외)
- [ ] **Audit:** Evidence/Revision 추적 가능한가? PIT 쿼리 있는가?
- [ ] **Necessity:** 근거 있는 변경인가? "혹시 필요하면" 아닌가?
- [ ] **Normalization:** 쓰기는 3NF, 읽기는 projection인가?
- [ ] **Simplicity:** 위→아래로 읽혀야 하는가? 숨겨진 전제 없는가?
- [ ] **Pattern:** 표준 Slice/Job/Component 따르는가? 새 패턴 도입은 검증됐는가?
- [ ] **Guardrails:** 근거 있는가? "왜"를 기록했는가?
- [ ] **Traceability:** Artifact 보존되는가? Reproduction 가능한가? ADR/Issue 링크 있는가?
- [ ] **Safety:** Idempotent인가? Rollback 가능한가? 부분 실패 케이스 처리했는가?
- [ ] **Maturity:** 임시방편 아닌가? Contract/schema/test 먼저 했는가?
- [ ] **Right Way:** Shortcut (--no-verify, force) 안 썼는가? 근본 해결했는가?
- [ ] **Debt:** 새로운 debt 만들지 않는가? 기존 debt 감축하는가?
- [ ] **Viewport Fit (UI):** 대시보드를 제외한 모든 업무 화면이 페이지 스크롤 없이 초기 로딩 시 100% 한눈에 들어오는가?
- [ ] **Button Standard (UI):** 상단 툴바(배치/등록), 행별 작업(수정/상세), 다중선택(일괄), 폼 푸터(취소/저장) 버튼 배치가 규칙 매트릭스를 따르는가?
- [ ] **Skeleton Loading (UI):** 로딩 상태 시 텍스트 대신 레이아웃에 반응하는 shimmer 스켈레톤(SkeletonLoader)이 제대로 노출되는가?
- [ ] **Empty State (UI):** 데이터 0건 또는 조회 결과가 없을 시 표준 EmptyStatePlaceholder(아이콘+설명+조치버튼)가 노출되는가?
- [ ] **Component Scale (UI):** 입력폼, 그리드, 버튼, 선택상자 높이/폰트가 중앙 토큰(`tokens.css`) 규격(헤더 30px, 행 28px, 컨트롤 28px, 폰트 12px)을 따르는가?

### Anti-Patterns (금지)

- ❌ "일단 만들고 나중에 리팩터" → Feature 초기부터 정공법
- ❌ "페이지에 창 스크롤바가 생기게 방치" → 대시보드 제외 모든 업무 화면은 Viewport-Fit Zero-Scroll 필수
- ❌ "버튼 위치 난잡 배치" → 상단 우측(페이지/배치), 행 내부(개별 CRUD), 선택바(일괄), 폼 푸터(저장/취소) 표준 무시 금지
- ❌ "로딩 시 '불러오는 중...' 텍스트 방치" → 반드시 레이아웃 맞춤형 애니메이션 스켈레톤(SkeletonLoader) 적용 필수
- ❌ "데이터 0건 시 빈 흰색 공간 방치" → 반드시 표준 EmptyStatePlaceholder 컴포넌트 렌더링 필수
- ❌ "개별 인라인 height/font style 난립" → 반드시 중앙 tokens.css / base.css 디자인 토큰 상속 필수
- ❌ "혹시 필요할까봐 추상화" → Necessity-driven만
- ❌ SELECT * / Generic Repository → Explicit columns, explicit logic
- ❌ "이건 작은 변경이라 테스트 스킵" → 모든 경로 characterize
- ❌ Timestamp를 직접 DateTime.Now → IClock 주입
- ❌ Policy 로직이 Job/Handler에 → Domain Policy만
- ❌ "나중에 monitoring 추가" → 배포 전 Metric/Alert/Runbook 필수
- ❌ Magic number → 근거 있는 상수, Policy ID로 추적
- ❌ "다른 모듈 테이블 조회" → Contract/Read Model만
- ❌ 스킵된 테스트 기록 안 함 → Debt register에 DECISION_REQUIRED

## Execution Protocol Addendum

### Before Any Change

- Read the current Source of Truth first: user-provided configuration, current schema, active contracts, and existing tests.
- Record `Source / Assumption / Unknown / Decision Required` in the Slice note before editing.
- Preserve user-fixed development and production configuration values. Never replace them with compose defaults, environment fallbacks, or guessed credentials.
- Classify the change as exactly one Vertical Slice or one behavior-preserving refactoring. Do not mix policy, schema, configuration, and unrelated cleanup.

### Database Test Routing

- Unit tests do not connect to a database.
- Integration and migration tests use the configured test database from the test project's Development settings.
- Production database access is read-only diagnostics only unless an explicitly approved production release step says otherwise.
- Before any destructive test-database operation, parse and verify the database name is the approved test database. Refuse all other names.
- Do not infer schema from a legacy migration file. Compare active runtime SQL, tests, and the current database schema first.

### Time and Timezone

- Persist instants in UTC with timezone-aware database types where the contract permits.
- Convert to KST only at display, reporting, scheduling, or MarketCalendar boundaries.
- Keep `IClock.UtcNow` as the application clock contract. A KST conversion requires an explicit contract and characterization test.
- Never change a timezone or reinterpret existing timestamps without a documented data-meaning decision and rehearsal evidence.

### Blockers Must Be Actionable

- Do not repeatedly report that work is blocked without a concrete resolution proposal.
- For each blocker, state: exact cause, safe options, recommended option, required command or approval, and the evidence that will be produced.
- If the user has provided the required authority or test resource, proceed within that scope instead of asking for the same approval again.
- If an external prerequisite is missing, perform all safe read-only checks first, then give one precise request to unblock the next Slice.

### Evidence and Completion

- Never claim completion from an intended command. Record the actual command result and artifact path.
- For migrations, preserve fresh-install, upgrade, re-run, and failure-rehearsal evidence before calling the Slice complete.
- When a change fails validation, revert or isolate the failed draft before starting the next Slice; do not leave an unapplied journal or partial scaffold as if it were approved.